This is great news, but there is a down side.  In the process of saving your home, you may lower your credit score. Anytime you are delinquent, have your payment adjusted or loan terms adjusted, you take a credit score hit.

Some homeowners who opted into a trial modification under Making Home Affordable are finding this out the hard way.  They make a few payments at the lower amount, only to find out their score has dropped.  Being in the trial program is no assurance they will even be accepted for permanent modification, yet they are penalized about 100 points just for asking for help.

The credit industry is, of course, quick to defend this practice of penalizing those who even ask for a change in loan terms.  The government realizes this is a side effect.  Consumer advocates deplore the practice on the grounds that people should not be zinged for trying to do the right thing.  All of these parties encourage people in trouble to ask for help before their homes go into foreclosure, but the credit score drop is a disincentive to many.

However, for most who seek help, this is an irrelevant side effect, especially if they are already behind on payments and close to losing their home. It’s like telling people on the sinking Titanic that they will be billed more if they chose a red lifeboat instead of a blue one.  If you’re drowning, you might prefer the blue one, however, if the red one is the only one in sight, paying more for red seems pretty reasonable.

Remedies such as loan modification, bankruptcy, and even short sale or foreclosure are last resort remedies that you might choose when you have no other options.  In a perfect world, you would be able to pay your bills without needing help.  In the real world, if you need help, your best option is to use the help accessible to you.  The time to ask is - as soon as you need it.  There may be a credit score impact with any remedy, but the impact is less the earlier you ask.

Express Homebuyers will buy your home for cash.  Call us today at 1-877-804-5252 or check out our helpful website.  We will make you an offer on your first call, provide free reports to help you make your selling decision, and even offer options to chat with one of our helpful consultants.

HAMP was conceived promptly to meet a crisis, so banks had to prepare to implement it quickly.  Participation in the program was voluntary and even banking giants who had developed their own programs for distressed homeowners did not embrace HAMP immediately.

Though banks have been paid incentives through all phases of HAMP, they have been slow to process modifications; the government has only paid $50 million.  Out of 3-4 million homes that Making Home Affordable hoped to saved, there have been only 170,000 permanent loan modifications so far.

There is lots of red tape involved in modifying a loan, but banks are still not set up to handle the waves of foreclosure, despite increased hiring of processing staff.  As a result, it takes a long time to process the paperwork that is justifiably involved in changing loans.

The Underlying Issues…

Banks may be dragging their feet as they, of course, prefer to have borrowers adhere to original loan terms.  In their defense, the ownership of these loans is complicated.  Many are backed by investors, so multiple investors hold mortgages.  How can these investments be valued?  Who loses what and how much?

Almost immediately, an irony shone through.  HAMP could only be successful if banks were on board, but forcing them to comply was (and is) an issue in itself.  In a free society, can a government force private businesses to rewrite loans and thereby threaten their investors’ pocketbooks?

The current crisis requires that banks pick up the pace in their responses and do so in a way that balances their needs as a business, the concerns of their investors, and the plight of distressed homeowners.  This is a tall order, but one that banks must fill if they ever hope to return to business as usual.

Looking to sell your home?  Express Homebuyers buys homes in DC, Maryland, and Virginia.  Call us today for a fair offer.  We buy homes for cash and you could have $2,500 in your hands even before your deal closes.

Under the latest change to the program, banks must offer 3-6 months payment relief to the unemployed. Banks are encouraged (but not required) to cut principle payments, which will be compensated by $75 billion in diverted HAMP funds.

The new guidelines are an attempt to address two major causes of foreclosure: unemployment and negative equity. The crisis started among subprime mortgages that reset but spread to other groups – especially those who lost their jobs or saw their housing values dive. When HAMP was hatched last year, it immediately met criticism because it did not adequately address either problem.

In the original program, HAMP did not demand that principal balances on loans be reduced – even though evidence available at the time showed that this was the most effective way to approach the problem, especially in view of the growing negative equity problem.  Now banks will be offered incentives to reduce principle, but it is still not mandatory that they do so.

The crisis is far from over. Over the next two years, 8 million more foreclosures are anticipated.  Pay-option mortgages will reset, making house payments so large homeowners cannot keep up. Many underwater homeowners finally give up, out of necessity or strategic decision. The current reinvention of HAMP is only expected to help a few hundred thousand people, a couple drops of water in a predicted tsunami of foreclosures.

Feel underwater?  Fearing foreclosure?  Express Homebuyers buys homes for cash in DC, Maryland, and Virginia.

Specifically, the researchers found that if a payment is lowered by 25% because the interest rate was cut, the homeowner is 11% less likely to default.  If the 25% deduction is due to reducing the principle while cutting the interest a little, the homeowner is 27% less likely to default within one year.  Reducing the principle doubles the potential rate of success.

Lenders and the investors who bought the loans are reluctant to lower the principle, even though the dollars and cents of foreclosure are clear: it costs more to foreclose and then maintain a bank-owned home until sold than to cut their losses by making a deal with the home owner.

Homeowners are acutely aware that the value of their home has dropped in comparison to the loan value.  Nationwide, at least 23% of homeowners had negative equity in their homes by the third quarter of 2009.  The Fed Study found that the more “underwater” a borrower is, the more likely he is to default.  When their loan–to-value (LTV) is 115%, homeowners owe 15% more than the home is worth and are 51% more likely to default on a modified loan.  When they have positive equity, they are more likely to keep the terms of the modification.

It comes down to incentive.  If people are paying on a deeply underwater home, they have less financial stake in paying on the loan than those who would lose their own money if they defaulted.  No one wants a foreclosure, but those with positive LTV would lose their equity along with the home in case of default and ultimate foreclosure.

Some analysts think the study could result in a rethinking of federal housing rescue plans.  Currently, the Home Affordable Modification Program (HAMP) stresses lowering interest and lengthening the mortgage but does not push for principle reduction.  If lessening the principle to get the home more in line with current market values is the key to successful mortgage modification, existing programs are doomed to failure or at least will have minimal long term effectiveness.  The program must encourage people to make the choice to pay rather than default.  Hopefully, future modifications of HAMP will tackle the thorny issue of underwater mortgage head on.

Facing the potential of having to sell your home? Express Homebuyers will buy your home for cash and have your deal wrapped up in two weeks .  Check our website for some useful secrets on selling your house fast. Then give us a call at 1-877-804-5252. We buy houses as a business. We pay cash, and you can sell your house fast to avoid the hassle of loan modification.

• While 4 million people could be helped, only 825,000 have been accepted into the program so far.
• Only 66,000 (7%) homeowners in the program have moved into permanent loan modifications.
• On average, homeowners save about $500 per month when their payments are reduced to a maximum of 31% of their income.
• Of the homeowners aided by program to date, 52% needed assistance because they lost income; 11% claimed too much non-mortgage debt; and 6% were unemployed.
• About 50,000 (6%) have been dropped from the program because they did not qualify, provide required documentation, or make all of their payments.
• 25% of participating homeowners have failed to make all of their payments while some have made none at all.

The statistics provided are interesting food for thought. Why aren’t more people applying?  Why aren’t more accepted?  Why aren’t more moving to permanent status?  Why are so many defaulting?

There is plenty of fault to go around.

Banks don’t really want to modify loans; when they do, they seldom modify the principle.  The modifications are doomed to fail for many people, especially if they are underwater and people are still paying big notes on homes that have lost their value.

The fact that some people aren’t paying their loans indicates that the modification wasn’t enough for them, their finances got worse after the modification – i.e., they lost their job, or the home they tried to stay is was too expensive for them.  Perhaps the program guidelines need to be changed or counseling needs to weed out those likely to fail and help them find new housing.

 Express Homebuyers can buy your home for cash to prevent foreclosure.  Check our list of frequently asked questions to see how this can help you, and then call 877-804-3252 to get started.